Pilchesky v. Gatelli, PICS Case No. 11-0045 (Pa. Super. Jan. 5, 2011) Freedberg, J.; Colville, J., concurring and dissenting (36 pages).

Superior Court

The Legal Intelligencer

Appellant appealed from the trial court's order directing him to disclose the identities of six John Doe defendants who appellee and cross-appellant Judy Gatelli claimed pseudonymously published defamatory statements about her on an Internet message board hosted by appellant. Appellee cross-appealed the order seeking the identities of eight additional John Doe defendants. The court quashed the appeals in part, vacated the order and remanded.