Pilchesky v. Gatelli, PICS Case No. 11-0045 (Pa. Super. Jan. 5, 2011) Freedberg, J.; Colville, J., concurring and dissenting (36 pages).
Appellant appealed from the trial court's order directing him to disclose the identities of six John Doe defendants who appellee and cross-appellant Judy Gatelli claimed pseudonymously published defamatory statements about her on an Internet message board hosted by appellant. Appellee cross-appealed the order seeking the identities of eight additional John Doe defendants. The court quashed the appeals in part, vacated the order and remanded.